Business analysis glossary
Acceptance and Evaluation Criteria
What it is
Acceptance criteria are the conditions a solution must meet to be accepted by stakeholders, while evaluation criteria are the measures used to compare options or judge a solution's value. The BABOK Guide treats them as one technique because both define in advance how a decision about a solution will be made.
Why it matters
Deciding the criteria before seeing the options keeps choices fair and objective. Evaluation criteria stop vendor demos or personal preferences from driving a decision, and acceptance criteria stop endless debates about whether work is done. Both make the final decision traceable and defensible.
Example
Choosing a new helpdesk tool, Skylark Software agrees evaluation criteria first: cost per agent, Hindi and English support, ticket API and data hosting in India. Three vendors are scored against them. For the chosen tool, acceptance criteria say that ticket import and email routing must work before the contract is signed.